PHABULOUSITY
  • Home
  • About
  • Authors
  • Books
    • Book: The Screaming Skull
    • Book: The Mace of Malice
    • Series: Chronicles of Elberon
  • Blog
  • Join the Guild
  • Submissions
  • Band Bracket

The Greatest American Rock Band Bracket!
First Round, Indie/Grunge/New Wave Division


Velvet Underground (2) vs. Big Star (15)

The original underground sensation versus the best band you've never heard of
The Velvet Underground:
"The Velvet Underground were largely ignored during heir original run from the mid-'60s into the early '70s, but few bands would cast as long a shadow in terms of innovation and influence. Playing music that was boldly uncompromising both sonically and lyrically, the Velvet Underground infused rock & roll with the daring of the avant-garde and the poetic realism of post-beat literature. Too far ahead of their time for pop music's mainstream, the VU made a profound impression on thoughtful listeners, many of whom would go on to make groundbreaking music of their own, and they would belatedly be acknowledged as one of rock's most important groups [and] for their incalculable influence upon the punk and new wave of subsequent years."
​​--AllMusic.com


Popularity
  • Over 810 thousand records sold worldwide
  • VU influence far outweighs their contemporary record sales

Influence:
  • Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, 1996
  • Ranked #19 on Rolling Stone's "100 Greatest Artists"
  • Generally regarded as the most influential rock band of all time behind the Beatles
Big Star:
"The quintessential American power pop band, Big Star remains one of the most mythic and influential cult acts in all of rock & roll. The Memphis-based group fused the strongest elements of the British Invasion era… into a ramshackle but poignantly beautiful sound that recaptured the spirit of pop's past even as it pointed the way toward the music's future. Although creative tensions, haphazard distribution, and marketplace indifference conspired to ensure Big Star's brief existence and commercial failure, the group's three studio albums nevertheless remain unqualified classics. Their impact on subsequent generations of indie bands on both sides of the Atlantic is surpassed only by that of the Velvet Underground."
--AllMusic.com

Popularity
  • Big Star hardly sold any albums while active
  • As with VU, influence far outweighs contemporary record sales

Influence:
  • All three Big Star albums included on Rolling Stone's "500 Greatest Albums" list
  • Cited as foundational influence by R.E.M., the Replacements, Kiss, and many other artists

Time to vote!

Submit

CLICK HERE TO GO BACK TO THE BRACKET!
All contents copyright 2023 Mr. Phabulous, LLC dba "Phabulousity."
All rights reserved

Mr. Phabulous, LLC
305 Cedar Dust Dr.
​Decatur, GA 30030

You may view our privacy policy here. 

  • Home
  • About
  • Authors
  • Books
    • Book: The Screaming Skull
    • Book: The Mace of Malice
    • Series: Chronicles of Elberon
  • Blog
  • Join the Guild
  • Submissions
  • Band Bracket